Sunday, April 10, 2022

Former Winn-Dixie #2316 - Rockledge, FL


Winn-Dixie #2316
624 Barnes Boulevard, Rockledge, FL - Three Meadows Plaza

     Last year on AFB, we toured the brand new Rockledge (Viera) Winn-Dixie, which opened in the city's former Earth Fare store. The opening of that new store brings Winn-Dixie back to the Brevard County city of Rockledge after a 16 year hiatus, filling a void in the company's footprint that had existed since the 2005 bankruptcy. Today's post will touch on the history of Winn-Dixie in Rockledge, and take us on a tour of the former 1990's Marketplace store in town.


     Long before the city's Marketplace store came into existence, two older Winn-Dixies that dated back to the 1960's served the shoppers of Rockledge. The oldest of those 1960's-era stores was the one featured in the Google Street View image above, located at 213 Dixie Lane. The opening of this Winn-Dixie coincided with the opening of the Searstown Shopping Center across the street, anchored by (obviously) Sears, as well as Publix. The 1961 Winn-Dixie store was built on a small side street at the southern edge of the Searstown complex, the street being a new access road to enter Searstown as well as providing access to the few businesses built along the side of the complex (like the Winn-Dixie). Since Winn-Dixie was the most prominent of the new stores to locate along this new road, the new road ended up getting named after The Beef People's new store, hence the name Dixie Lane (which the road is still called today). Winn-Dixie closed this store by the early 1970's, consolidating their operations in town into a 1968-built store at the corner of Barton and Fiske Boulevards. The history of the 1968 Winn-Dixie is covered in this post over on AFB, as the site of that store has a tie-in with an Albertsons that never came to be. That 1968 store was quite outdated by the mid-1990's, leading it to be replaced by a new Winn-Dixie Marketplace a few miles south in 1995 - the store we'll be looking at in more detail today:


     Opening in 1995, the new Winn-Dixie Marketplace store in Rockledge was a fairly average build for the time. The new Marketplace was built at the corner of Barnes Boulevard and Murrell Road, the southernmost edge of Rockledge's city limits. The location at Barnes and Murrell put Winn-Dixie right at the edge of the up-and-coming Viera mega development, a development that would bring thousands of new residents to Central Brevard County. Sadly, by the time Winn-Dixie's 2005 bankruptcy came around, Viera was still in its infancy, and development was only just beginning to boom in the area. With Winn-Dixie in financial trouble, a massive closure wave that included 326 locations was released, the Rockledge location one of the many casualties on the list.


     The Rockledge Winn-Dixie Marketplace sat empty until 2008, when the left half of the building was converted into an Aldi. The Rockledge Aldi opened as part of the chain's initial push into Central Florida, an expansion effort that took advantage of the many buildings Winn-Dixie had vacated at the time. While Aldi came along in 2008, it took until 2016 to fill the remaining half of the former Winn-Dixie building. Sky Zone Trampoline Park would be the one to fill the rest of the building, and we'll see a few photos of Sky Zone's side of the building later in the post. Today's post mixes together set of photos I took in 2015 (featuring exterior shots of the building and a close-up of the abandoned half) and a set from 2021 (which profiles the Aldi half of the building in more detail and has some updated exterior photos following Sky Zone's arrival). So yes, quite a bit of change happened in the time between those two photosets, as in addition to Sky Zone moving in, Aldi also did a massive remodel to their half of the building too.


     Compared to the previous image (which was part of my 2015 batch), here's what Aldi's exterior looks like today. Like most Aldi stores out there, this one was remodeled to the company's latest design. I really like Aldi's new look, and we'll take a quick peek at that in the following images.


     As with most cases of Aldi taking over a piece of a former supermarket building, nothing was left behind from the previous tenant inside. As part of the recent remodel, Aldi added their latest facade design to the exterior too, which looks a bit odd next to the rest of the untouched Winn-Dixie Marketplace facade (photos showing the two designs together coming up later in the post).


     On the front sidewalk, that wall in the distance is where Winn-Dixie's entryway used to be.


     Stepping inside the Aldi half of the building, you enter into the produce department. You're also greeted by a large sign, and I like how Aldi has been adding the city names to these Welcome signs in the recent remodels.


     Entering the produce department, we find a few displays set at an angle. Aldi's typical modern store design features one long produce display as you enter, situated as part of the regular grocery aisles. Aldi's stores that tend to skew a bit larger get the angled produce aisle treatment we see here.


     Here's a view from the back of the produce department looking toward the front of the store. To fill up some of the extra space, Aldi placed extra bins of produce at the back of the department for popular items (like bananas) and large produce items (watermelon). Produce also got its own fancy lighting treatment too, with spotlights and fixtures that follow the angled contour of the aisles.


     Entering the grocery aisles, it's back to the usual Aldi feel. When the store received its most recent remodel, the decor was swapped out for the much nicer backlit graphics we see here, the aisles were shuffled around a bit, and the ceiling was painted black from its original white (here's a comparison photo from before the remodel). The yellow tile floor is the only remnant from when Aldi first opened here, and was a common design feature in Aldi's older stores. Aldi's new stores use a polished patterned concrete instead of the tile, the polished concrete matching the vibe of the rest of the decor better than the old yellow tiles.


     I've always felt that Aldi had the cleanest and most organized stores of the discount grocery chains out there, but Aldi really stepped up their game in these latest stores and remodels. Aldi is expanding like crazy in Florida right now, doing a lot of infill in the Peninsula and embarking on an expansion into the Panhandle. I believe the new image is really helping the company too, as Aldi is actually starting to become a "trendy" place to shop (compared to their old image of being the bare-bones store where all the cheapskates went).


     Here's a look across the back of the store, with meats and cheeses in the cases on the back wall.



     The last aisle is home to more dairy products, although the aisle expands as it nears the front of the store to allow for a frozen food alcove.


     Moving further up that same aisle, here it is with the frozen foods department coming into view.


     Our final interior photo from Aldi looks across the store's front end, back toward produce. When Winn-Dixie was here, from this vantage point, we'd have been looking toward the pharmacy (which would have been immediately to my left) and the bakery, which occupied the front left corner where Aldi's entrance is now.


     Back outside, here's a look toward the Sky Zone half of the building. Besides removing the awning in the middle of the tower, Sky Zone didn't alter much from the original Marketplace design on the facade.


     Before we jump to the present for a closer look at Sky Zone, let's go back in time to 2015, prior to them moving in. Back then, the right side of the building was much more interesting, and contained many more traces from the Winn-Dixie days!


     Aldi's portion of the old Winn-Dixie space ends where Winn-Dixie's entryway was. If you were to walk through these doors and look to the left, you'd be greeted immediately by the partition wall.


     Looking the other way, we can see that wall through the window from this angle. What we see here was Winn-Dixie's typical Marketplace-era entryway configuration, with the entrance being the double doors on the right side of the vestibule, and the exit being the two doors in the middle. When Sky Zone moved in, they reconfigured the doors to make a single entrance/exit where the two exit doors are located here, and sealed over the old entry door with a new window.


     Peeking through the glass, we can see where Winn-Dixie's old salesfloor abruptly ends at the new partition wall installed by Aldi. While Aldi gutted their half of the building at the time, everything was left untouched in the other half, leaving the odd sight of these vents and wires dangling from the ceiling where they were unceremoniously chopped off.


     Moving further to the right, we can see some small traces of the Marketplace decor. The check lanes would have been located under the lower ceiling immediately in front of me, the grocery aisles extending out beyond that.


     If you look really close at the floor, the old Marketplace tile pattern is still there. While it looks like the old tile floor was ripped out, it wasn't. It appears it was just really dirty, probably covered in a layer of construction dust from when the building was subdivided.


     Our last interior photo was taken through the old entry doors, looking toward the former produce department in the front right corner.


     A 'DELI' and 'PHARMACY' labelscar was still visible on the far right side of the facade when I visited in 2015...


     …and believe it or not, between the new paint and the addition of the silhouettes of jumping people, that same labelscar is still visible today too! The labelscar is really obvious in person, but you can still see it if you zoom in on the photo above.


     At the other side of the building now, we can see the odd pairing of the old Winn-Dixie facade with Aldi's new design. This certainly isn't the weirdest facade to come out of a subdivision that I've seen, but it's pretty strange nonetheless!


     The repainting of the old Marketplace tower above Sky Zone's entrance to that bright blue color also makes for a strange sight, sticking out from the other neutral colors the building is painted. Painting it blue was better than removing the tower completely though.


     While Sky Zone left most of the exterior alone, as you would probably expect, the interior was totally gutted, and no traces of the old Marketplace decor remain inside.


     When this Winn-Dixie closed back in 2005, it probably seemed like a long shot that Winn-Dixie would ever return to town. However, jumping ahead 15 years we find ourselves with a renewed Winn-Dixie that has a strong desire to prove itself once again, returning to Rockledge with a new store, and plans to return to more communities they've vacated over the years too. For a long time we were wondering what stores Winn-Dixie would be closing next, but now we find ourselves faced with a new question - where will Winn-Dixie be opening a new store next?! It's crazy how the supermarket scene works in Florida, but like most things in Florida, it's best to not question how we do things down here too much!

    Sorry for the long stretch between posts here on MFR my myself, but hopefully I'll get around to bringing more to the blog soon. As usual there's plenty going on over at AFB, so be sure to jump over there next week for our next Floridian supermarket adventure, and be sure to check back on MFR for any new posts from myself and the other contributors too!

So until the next post,

AFB

6 comments:

  1. Whoa, not only do we get posts on AFB on consecutive weeks, but we also get a MFR post as well! I'm certainly not going to complain, but us AFB/MFR readers might get spoiled by this kind of service, lol!

    Although this Aldi is only a couple of years older than our oldest Aldis here in Houston, I don't think I've ever seen an Aldi here with a tile floor. In fact, I don't think I've seen those fancy concrete floors either, but perhaps I have not been in a new enough Aldi. Our stores, at least the ones I've been to, just have plain concrete. At least it isn't tile scarred like Kroger Koncrete and at least it isn't tile scarred with potholes in it like HEB concrete. 'Here Everything's Better'...yeah, right!. On top of that, this Aldi looks bigger than our Aldis. Certainly the facade is a lot nicer than most of our bespoke Aldi locations. I don't know if this is just a one-off oddity or if Aldi is trying harder to compete against the Publixes of the world than some of the more slovenly grocers we have here in Houston.

    I've been in Aldi a few times here lately as I've been drawn in by low advertised prices on produce. That said, it seems to me that some of their produce isn't quite up to the standards of other grocers. Things like strawberries often look (and taste) like seconds compared to what, say, Kroger or Randall's sells. Then again, they do have lower prices on those items than even HEB so perhaps the trade-off is acceptable for some. I wouldn't say that Aldi is trendy here (though Aldi Nord's Trader Joe's certainly is in the areas of Houston that has them), but I do think they do have a core of customers who find Aldi to be less crazy than other low price grocers in town such as Walmart and HEB. At least here in Houston, Aldi's Google user reviews are sky high. They're pretty much in Publix/HEB type territory with those and they may even beat the competing HEB in the ratings in some areas.

    LIDL was supposed to come to Houston a few years ago. They had land to build stores in Houston and they even submitted all their regulatory paperwork, but then the locations were never built. LIDL looks like a step above Aldi so perhaps they could have done well here, but we may never know since it seems LIDL has sold off their land here. I've heard of quick supermarket failures in Houston such as Food Lion and Albertsons, just to name two familiar names to you, but LIDL's failure might have been even more spectacular than those!

    Oh, on the topic of Winn-Dixie, check out this supermarket in the Dallas area! This ought to look familiar! Link: https://goo.gl/maps/8vfS7fNHVFhnRTUp8

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, depending on time, I have a few other posts for the future where I'm looking to do complementary AFB and MFR posts on the same day. I think it's a nice format to post related stores, without making individual posts too long!

      The tile floors inside Aldi matched the old aesthetic much better, but don't look too out of place with the new decor either. I don't know exactly when Aldi stopped using tile in favor of the polished concrete, but it was sometime in the early 2010's. This store is a little bigger than the average Aldi, but that's mostly because the aisles are more spaced out than usual - the product selection is pretty much the same as any Aldi. Aldi is expanding really hard in Florida, and I see people in here all the time with full carts (and on a few cases, two full carts!) Aldi is finding a niche in Florida, which is nice, as it's great to have grocery options here that aren't Publix!

      I actually buy most of my produce at Aldi, as it's the best price in town, and the quality doesn't seem too bad from my experience. I actually do most of my grocery shopping at Aldi (sorry Publix, don't hurt me!) and the pricing is even lower than Walmart (and I do all I can to not have to venture into Walmart). Aldi's new spin on being the "nicest" low-price grocery store seems to be working well though, as the company is in a huge expansion mode and people are following. Aldi isn't trying to be super trendy like their sister chain Trader Joe's, but they have done a lot to win over younger shoppers with the new trendy vibe and rise in popularity of off-brand products.

      I remember Texas was supposed to be one of Lidl's original expansion markets when they entered the US, but when initial sales were slower than they'd expected, they backed out of those plans. It seems like Lidl is holding their own in the areas where they are now, but I think they made a number of miscalculations in their first few years of entering the US. Jumping right into Houston with those initial miscalculations probably wouldn't have bode well for the chain's success in Houston.

      Foodland Marketplace! That floor tile pattern seems like it will never die!

      Delete
  2. Wow! I really like Aldi's new facade design! I was hoping for a situation like this at #4355, but apparently it's not the case. The black painted ceilings also give off a cool vibe. Now if they could just throw some stars up there, you could have a truly cosmic grocery shopping experience (which I find very fitting for the space coast).

    It would have looked better with the tower painted a charcoal color like the Aldi next door, than the blue. It's nice to at least see the plaza lively again and not a lonely Aldi.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Aldi would have been perfect for old #4355, especially since they were picking up additional former Lucky's locations after the bankruptcy too.

      A charcoal or brown color would have tied in with the rest of the plaza much better, but I guess if nothing else, the blue makes Sky Zone's entrance stand out!

      Delete
  3. I'm glad you were able to get some pictures of the Winn-Dixie before a new tenant moved in! I agree that the current façade looks very strange, but at least Sky Zone managed to keep some memories of WD alive. I do, however, feel like their marketing team could have picked some better paint colors (even if blue and orange are their main colors).

    With regards to Aldi, I have been to a few of their stores but mostly think they are more boring and cookie-cutter than a modern Publix! While Publix can at least have some tile variation between service departments, or floorplan variation, almost every Aldi looks the same to me on the inside (save the floors). I guess that is one similarity between these two chains: lack of variety (especially compared to Kroger who seems to have countless "current" décor packages).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Those photos of the abandoned half of the old Winn-Dixie were taken only a few months before Sky Zone moved in (which I didn't know was the plan when those photos were taken). I'm glad I got that glimpse of the interior, before all traces of the building's original Marketplace interior were wiped away. At least the exterior remodel kept alive the legacy of what used to be here, rather than the entire facade getting rebuilt for someone else.

      It's true, every Aldi does look the same, even in buildings that were taken over from other tenants. I think that consistency is another one of their cost saving measures. It seems like every local Aldi remodeled to the new look pretty quick too, like Publix does when a new decor rolls out.

      Delete