Friday, July 22, 2022

56M-1: The Hybrid Format - Publix #1363 - Brookhaven, GA


Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Publix #1363

Town Brookhaven

104 Town Blvd Ste A100

Brookhaven, GA 30319

Previously, I was unaware that Sienna (CM 3.0) and Invigorate (CM 2.5) both made their debut in 2010. I also didn't realize that Publix's second-generation 54M prototype first-gen 56M prototype was the first store to introduce the world to the Sienna Environment Package. So far, I have learned of three "Hybrid Format" concepts which were designed to incorporate elements from a standard Publix and a GreenWise store to create a more premium shopping experience. While I was anticipating to capture this store with all of its early Sienna design quirks, I missed the mark by a few months and found this store had been Evergreen'd. Although I was upset to find that some of the more unique aspects of this store had been wiped away, I still got to see some strong influences from the Hybrid concept which live on to this day, in addition to remnants of 2011's prototype version of Sienna.

I've now been to three 2011-2012 era Sienna stores and all of them seem to be located in wealthier areas of the Atlanta Metro. It seems as if Publix initially intended for Sienna to be the décor used in premium stores while Invigorate targeted the majority of the Publix footprint. I've also learned that there were three distinct eras of Sienna, with the third being the most common, the second being fairly wide-spread, and the first, which this store originally featured, being very elusive.  Although this store has been remodeled to Evergreen, we will get to see some of the unique aspects that still remain. If you want to have a better idea of how this store looked when it opened, AFB posted about its sister location (the third Hybrid Format store) back in 2019 and was able to capture a few of the early Sienna oddities.  We can't take a time machine back to see how this store looked a year ago, but we can see how it looks in 2022; let's check it out!

The Store

Publix #1363 opened on April 21, 2011, as the second largest ITP Atlanta store (behind 1996's #536).  It still surprises me to see such a large supermarket built within Atlanta's I-285 perimeter; with that being said, this store was constructed on top of a parking garage to allow it to fit in a more condensed space. Another unique aspect I notice from the picture above is how the store has two exits. Typically, the modern 54M-2 will only have one entry and one exit, both centered on the store.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Walking inside, we see the typical cart storage area between the two sets of doors. This is one time when I was really saddened to not find any green beans!

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Much of this section of the store will look familiar to anybody who has been to a second-gen 54M. The primary exception I see is the café and accompanying seating area. Publix seems to only build cafés in more premium markets.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Taking a look back over the front end, nothing looks too out of place here. The main thing I noticed was the island containing various lottery forms. It seems like these are typically placed in a branded fixture against a wall, and not in a Publix-supplied cabinet. This store also managed to keep its original round customer service island. Both earlier CM 2.0 and later Invigorate / Sienna stores also have a section of dropped ceiling within the ring hanging from the ceiling, but this store's was just hollow.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Stepping into the produce department, I see a few things that Publix decided to change in later stores. The first is the green arc. In newer stores, the orientation of this was flipped and shifted toward the coolers. Additionally, "Produce" signage would have been attached to this and not simply hung independently.

Is it just me, or does anybody else feel like the green on the arc clashes with the brown ceilings in this store?

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Looking over toward the bakery in the front right corner, we see a sight that looks pretty familiar. We also can catch a glimpse of the edge of the café in this shot. I would like to point out how the bakery received mosaic tiles between the larger blue tiles; this is a pretty consistent sign of a store which was built before the 2016 (3rd-gen) Sienna refresh.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Next, we see the deli, hot food bar, and specialty cheese island. While this may look similar to other stores, there a few subtle differences. The first is that only premium stores receive a hot food bar or a specialty cheese island. Others would just have coolers in these locations with various cheeses or pre-made deli products. The other thing is how the sliced meats counter was swapped with the chicken and sandwich station in this store, compared to later builds of the 54M-2

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

I really wish I had seen this store before it was remodeled, because it previously featured a unique wood-grained deli department sign.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

With a quick look back toward the front, we see the café and seating area which call the "multipurpose nook" to the right of the door home. Similar to the space in the front right corner of 42N & 49N stores, I have seen a number of different departments call this space home in the 54M-2.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

This store still placed wine in the back right corner, but it looks as if it received more premium wooden shelving and a sommelier desk. It also retained a painted version of its round Sienna department signage.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Let's take one last look at the grand aisle before we move on.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

I wonder how often this store has a wine specialist on-site because this station looks fairly empty.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

I did manage to take a picture of this tile pattern though; you won't see this one in any-ole Publix!

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Next, we'll move onto the seafood department. This is another department which had unique signage back in its Sienna days because it looks like it featured lights with a wave pattern.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

One of the easiest ways to identify an early Sienna remodel is this unique brown tile pattern behind the seafood counter. Publix eventually landed on this blue one, and it seems most of the prototypes, whether new builds or remodels, received that treatment.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

This store also seems to have received seafood display cases which look more premium than the ones in a standard Publix.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Here is another angle of the meat counter, and its striated muscle tile pattern.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Aisles 1 & 2 are recessed a bit from the main actionway and have a specials island in the extra space.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

We'll take one more look at meat & seafood before we move on.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Aisle 4 is home to canned vegetables and pasta.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

One big thing I noticed while wandering the grocery aisles of this store was the presence of these specialty endcaps every few aisles. Most of them seemed to feature gourmet or organic items, which would make sense with this store being a "Hybrid".

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Returning to the back aisle, this view looks largely the same as any 54M-2. The one indicator of this store's status is the premium endcap on the edge of the frame.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Aisle 5 houses this store's selection of crackers, cookies, and office supplies . . .

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

in addition to candy!

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Aisle 7 has beer and snacks, while aisle 8 contains the first half of frozen. I've also noticed how some stores' Evergreen aisle signs look like this and feature green frames, while others have grey frames.  I believe Publix recycled the green Sienna frames wherever they could but opted to purchase grey frames for most new-builds or non-Sienna remodeled stores.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

I was hoping to channel more of my puns / sarcasm for this post, but nothing in these pictures seems to be calling my name.  Anyway, between the brown-tinted terrazzo, brown coolers, and brown ceiling, I think this store's interior is more EverBrown than EverGreen.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Aisle 9 has the remainder of frozen food and some nice khaki colored refrigerators – not the color I would've picked!

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

The remaining grocery aisles seem to be laid out the same as most other modern Publix stores. I would like to point out how this store has two emergency exits in this corner of the store, compared to most typically only having one; maybe this relates to the store's slightly larger size as a 56M? We also can see another GreenWise display on the endcap.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Aisle 14 features soap and cosmetics.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

I'm not sure if you'll find this in a regular Publix (because I haven't really looked), but I noticed that this store had a random section of organic or specialty dental hygiene products next to the standard fare. I think the idea behind the "Hybrid Format" was to sprinkle sections like this throughout the store to provide a more upscale selection of products.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Meanwhile, aisle 15 is where you'll find yogurt, cheeses, and butter. I find it odd that water is also on this aisle, because the non-refrigerated space is typically reserved for bread, peanut butter, and jelly in other prototypes. Although the aisle signs list bread and jelly as being on this aisle, I don't see it in my pictures!

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

I do like the glass tiles Publix used for their pharmacy counters with Sienna.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Now we'll take a look at the "front speedway" as Publix calls it. If you didn't notice, this store also got more premium shelving for these pharmaceutical aisles in the front of the store.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

This store may not have as many cards as #1228 which we toured a few weeks ago, but it still looks like a lot when it takes up the entire side of an aisle.  Greeting cards must have some high margins!

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

I've previously seen this collage in another Evergreen store, but I love how the designers in this package decided to leave a subtle gesture toward this store's Sienna past. The green beans may no longer be by the entrance and the artichoke may not be in the produce department, but they are still here!

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

The honeycomb pattern also does look nice above the pharmacy.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

In the edge of this picture, you can see this store's second set of exit doors, which feels really odd if you are used to seeing the very similar 54M-2.  This seems to be a defining feature of 56M stores, or a 50,000 sq. ft. prototype I recently discovered in North Carolina.  We can also see more of the wood shelving where customers can find various supplements and health products.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

While these aisles of pharmaceuticals look rather standard, I did notice that the two "vitamins" category markers did not match. I'm not sure whether this was intentional, or if one was new and one was left over from Sienna (I've never paid much attention to how these vary between décors).

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Adding to the premium feel, this store also received a goat soap display.  As I've mentioned before, these seem to be reserved for higher-end locations.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Something I had never previously seen in a Publix were these fancy drink/snack coolers by the registers

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

It looks like Publix even went through the effort to add the Evergreen-style grey wood grain to these as an update.

Since I always seem to catch Publix with some sort of holiday decorations, this particular trip found the store making preparations for Passover.  However, I didn't notice much besides this sign acknowledging the religious celebration.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Another sign of this store's premium nature is the presence of an Apron's Catering counter.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Another fun tile pattern which you don't see every day!

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

We'll take one last look at the Café and entry door before we prepare the cabin for departure.

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

 A final thing I wanted to point out is how this store still sold bulk coffee. I don't remember the last time I saw bulk coffee with the accompanying grinder in a Publix, but I used to love smelling the different beans and asking to buy some just so I could use the grinder!

Publix #1363 - Town Brookhaven - Brookhaven, GA - Evergreen Interior - The Sing Oil Blogger

Interestingly, Publix didn't bother to change out the customer service island with the newer style of desk. I also noticed how Publix simply painted over the wood veneer on the "service" circle hanging from the ceiling because the Sienna wood pattern could still be seen between the outer ring and the inner light ring.  Regardless, that is probably something only a devout retail blogger would pick up on!

And that will conclude our tour of Publix's second store to feature the modern 54M layout (in a 56M) and the Sienna interior package. While I'm sad that I didn't manage to visit this store while it still had Classy Market 3.0, it was still a cool experience. Until next time!

- The Sing Oil Blogger

4 comments:

  1. Anonymous in HoustonJuly 22, 2022 at 10:29 PM

    Ha, Everbrown! I can see why you would say that though! That said, it's not the brown here which bothers me. It's all the nEvergreen grey! Ugh, what a depressing color. While this store isn't in Florida, I can't think of a less Floridian color than grey! People move to Florida (and Georgia) to avoid the grey! Of course, thunderstorms and grey are inevitable in the south as we all know, but the grey from that isn't something we celebrate!

    I was reading the news from Canada a few weeks back and saw a report in the CBC that grey might well be on the way out as a trendy interior paint color: https://www.cbc.ca/life/home/2022-interior-paint-trends-to-consider-before-choosing-your-colour-1.6472712

    I can only hope that is true! Some retailers have integrated grey in an acceptable manner. I think Safeway's Colorful Lifestyle v2 does a great job using grey with brighter colors to make a great decor package. That's a rare thing though. We otherwise usually get excessively industrial looking retail which just doesn't look good. If grey is indeed on the way out, perhaps Publix has even more reason to reassess nEvergreen!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As I've said before, Evergreen may not be my favorite package, but I'll take a a sad grey any day over a jarring yellow or red with all-caps font . . . I still think my least favorite part of this store was the khaki / mustard colored freezers and refrigerators though. Although grey is only Floridian due to the ample thunderstorms in the state, Publix is just embracing the trend of the minute like they did with pastels in the 1990's or muted yellows and greens in the 2000's. As a fellow Southerner, I too would much rather sunshine as opposed to a cloudy or stormy day.

      It would be interesting if they greys are fading away; I guess Publix could have been a bit late to that party (or thunderstorm).

      It is nice to see retailers like Safeway use neutrals as a backdrop for warm accents. I feel like Publix was attempting this with the green stripe around the perimeter of most stores but it doesn't have quite the same effect when a cool bold color is used versus a warm bold. At least Publix hasn't embraced the trend of concrete floors and seems to remain happy with terrazzo!

      Delete
  2. The Evergreen decor clashes so bad with the brown ceiling from Sienna. I've seen this effect in person too and it looks so off, as brown and gray really don't go well together! (And the yellow trim coolers clash just as much). I'm sure repainting the ceiling is a time consuming and expensive endeavor, but the gray ceilings pair so much better with the Evergreen decor!

    #1363 was of the same generation as #1398, which you can tour here when the store still had its original Sienna decor: https://myfloridaretail.blogspot.com/2019/01/publix-1398-rockledge-viera-fl-stadium.html

    I haven't been to #1398 in a while, but I've been told it recently remodeled to Evergreen too. I don't know if #1398 was the third hybrid store, but it was very much built in the same vein as #1363 and not the later 54M stores (as it also has the odd secondary exit by the pharmacy and identical features to this location). I'll be posting pictures from the original Sienna store before long, however by the time I got there that store also remodeled to Evergreen. Publix did modify the layout of #1337 a bit, with some notable changes in the grand aisle. Surprisingly, this location did not get the modifications both #1337 and #1398 got in their Evergreen remodels, as those stores received larger cafes and a relocated catering desk.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, the brown really does clash with all of the cool grey colors in the rest of the store! Luckily, there are still plenty of stores from the 1990's which retain their original white ceilings! I, however, still think the khaki / mustard / yellow coolers are the worst offenders. Who knows what these stores will look like in 5 years when Publix remodels them to the next package; maybe the brown will look much better.

      It totally slipped my mind that you had covered #1398, but I managed to add a link to that post in the second paragraph. I'm surprised that both #1398 and #1337 received layout changes as part of the remodel because #1363 seemed to look the same as it would've in 2011.

      Delete